Paterson high school graduation rate dropped two years in a row | Paterson Times

Paterson high school graduation rate dropped two years in a row


After years of non-stop increase, Paterson high school graduation rate has been declining over the past two academic years.

Data shows the district’s graduation rate dropped to 84.8 percent in 2018, down three points from the previous year. In 2019, the rate dropped another 5.6 points to 79.2 percent.

School board president Kenneth Simmons said the drop last year is attributed to the change in the way the state calculates graduation rates.

State officials confirmed the change that was made in 2019. The change ensures students attending an alternative school that were not submitted with a “regular or vocational” receiving or resident school were included in the district’s graduation rate, said a New Jersey Department of Education spokesman.

But the change does not explain the drop in 2018.

Superintendent Eileen Shafer’s spokesman did not respond to a message for comment.

Some school board members were unaware of the drop when the Paterson Times inquired about the decline in late April. School district business administrator Richard Matthews publicly told school board members about the graduation rate drop during a budget presentation on May 8.

“We’re going to have to buckle down and figure out what it is. Numbers don’t lie. It’s obviously a problem now,” said school board member Corey Teague.

The district’s high school graduation rate was at 45.6 percent in 2009. It increased every year until 2017, when the rate peaked at nearly 88 percent.


Shafer was tasked, as part of her merit goals, with increasing the district’s graduation rate by 2 percent in 2019, but she had to do it by decreasing the number of students graduating via an alternative route called the “portfolio” method by 5 percent.

“She just got a bonus,” said Teague. “How do you justify your bonus with graduation rate dropping?”

Shafer received a $19,400 bonus payment for 2019-20 school year. She could have collected $34,926 in bonuses on top of her $233,000 salary, but she fell short on two — increasing graduation rate and boosting standardized English exam scores — of the five merit goals.

Email: [email protected]

  • John

    In South Paterson (Muslim area) graduation did not decrease. Wake up Americans.

    • HankMorgan

      I must have missed the breakdown of student religious affiliation and graduation rate.

  • HankMorgan

    Does anyone else question how this loser district doubled rates of graduation in six years? I bet those “portfolios” contain more than a few coloring books stamped “Pass” by rigorous evaluators.

    And, look, for or Shafer, it’s all about the Benjamins. She takes that money, buys matching Benzes for herself and her spouse and cruises down to LBI to spend weekends at her shore home.

  • MarquinhoGaucho

    The effects of charters draining funds, resources and cherry picking the best students while dumping failing students after October when the budgets are set back in PPS in a trick called "attrition" in fact only 25% of Charter freshman actually graduate as seniors in the same school. They "juke the numbers"….another reason is that due to charters Paterson has cut successful alternative programs such as YES and Silk City , so these at risk students have no where to go and hence dont graduate

    • bigron

      I see the same comments from you on every story. Have you ever thought about management and leadership? Paterson schools are they way they are because people in charge care more about their fat checks than your children.

      • HankMorgan

        Marq knows what’s up. We’re on the same team.

      • MarquinhoGaucho

        4 member sof the BOE are charter lackeys, they follow the playbook, 1) defund, 2) create a failing system 3) Parents get angry 4) privatize . Schafer called ou the Charters and they made her shut up realllly quick and made her march for more money from Trenton…eventually there will be no more Public schools and they will go full charter like New Orleans which is at the bottom of all big cites in ed

  • Helen Hickmon

    The picture shows an African-American student falsely representing the population of the school which is now 75-80 percent Hispanic. Perception is EVERYTHING!